When we feel bad, we want to feel better. The positivity movement tells us we can get there by thinking positive thoughts.
There’s a lethal catch, though.
The hidden message is that feeling better requires us to suppress, negate, or numb everything except positive emotions. By pushing away half of what it means to be fully and wholly human, we also push away half the wisdom and guidance available to show us how to feel better at our core instead of only on our surface.
There’s no such thing as selective suppressing. Numbing any one feeling effectively numbs them all.
Brené Brown made this point years ago in Daring Greatly, but there’s more to it than losing joy along with pain. When we suppress a feeling, we also lose what it came to tell us.
What happens with those other emotions we are designed to feel? The so-called “negative” or “bad” ones? Where do they go when we attempt to numb, push away, gloss over, stuff down, or ignore them?
They don’t go away, so what really happens?
First, a recap:
We are designed to experience all emotions, the entire spectrum, each serving its own purpose. Anger tells us a line has been crossed. Grief tells us what mattered. When we label some as “good” and others as “bad,” some as “positive” and others as “negative,” we condemn ourselves to living a half-life, even though we claim to want a rich, fulfilling life. This leads to a life that feels like something is missing, where love and belonging can only be experienced superficially, incompletely, and transactionally.
The evidence that positivity alone isn’t working is obvious, though we may not recognize it. That’s because we’ve been so well-conditioned and culturized to believe the escalating feelings of anger, frustration, and hopelessness that naturally result from the numbing must also be pushed away, stuffed down, or glossed over by something more positive. Every time one of those “bad” feelings pops up – and they always do – we are besieged with self-anger, self-guilt, and self-failure, increasing the generalized feelings of anger, frustration, and hopelessness.
Research backs this up. In a study of more than 1,300 adults, researchers at UC Berkeley found that people who habitually accept their hard emotions end up experiencing fewer of them and have better psychological health overall. The people who typically pushed those feelings away reported more distress – and six months later, more symptoms of mood disorders.
Fighting the feeling feeds it.
True confession: November 1995, driving home from a visit with my sister, I spent the entire three-and-a-half-hour drive soaking in the delight of feeling completely relaxed, seen, and heard, and wondering what it would take to feel that way all the time. That question knocked me right back into dissatisfaction, with one difference: now I also felt angry and guilty at my own discontent. I had all the trappings of The Good Life. Why wasn’t it enough? (Have you ever wondered why we say the “trappings of The Good Life, the “trappings” of wealth, the “trappings” of _________?)
So I doubled down on changing my thoughts to more positive ones. This time, it didn’t offer even the illusion of working. I had been using positive thinking as a place to hide in plain sight, a way to bypass a lifetime of wounded feelings.
Yet pushing those feelings away didn’t erase the feelings or the memories of what caused them in the first place. Instead, those memories – both conscious and subconscious – lingered, producing more of the same feelings and the beliefs that come with them, and triggering more unhelpful behaviors and habits.
No feeling is bad. But some of what we’ve been taught about feelings is toxic.
Most of us learned those teachings early:
-
Good girls don’t show angry.
-
Be grateful – other people have it worse.
-
Don’t cry, or I’ll give you something to cry about.
We are conditioned and culturized to believe some feelings are acceptable and others make us weak, ungrateful, unattractive, or too much.
That’s also why changing our thoughts can only take us so far. We’re working on the surface while the story and feelings underneath stay in charge.
Conclusion? There’s no such thing as selective numbing.
When you numb your anger, you also numb your joy. When you bottle up your grief, you also bottle up your aliveness.
What feels like the biggest barrier to letting yourself experience all your feelings including uncomfortable or painful emotions?
Reflection: Finish the Sentence
The next time a feeling shows up that you’d usually push away, name it plainly. “I’m angry.” “I’m sad.” “I’m disappointed.” No softening, no silver lining. Then ask yourself two questions:
• Who taught me I’m not supposed to feel this?
• What would this feeling tell me if I let it finish its sentence?
You don’t have to act on the feeling or fix it. Let it speak long enough to hear what it came to say. You may find the feeling isn’t the problem. The rule about the feeling is.
StoryShift the Book – Preorders opening in October 2026. Launching November 8, 2026.
Are you willing to learn how to feel and receive wisdom from your entire emotional spectrum? Do you sometimes wonder how pain from your past is still affecting you now? The StoryShift Self-Assessment is designed to help you pinpoint where old emotional wounds are shaping your life today. Take the FREE QUIZ for personalized feedback.